You paid your premiums. You finished the jobs. Then another insurance bill arrived.
Your first thought might be: “I already paid for this policy.”
On an auditable policy, the starting premium is generally based on estimates. After the policy period ends, the carrier reviews your actual business activity to determine whether an adjustment is needed.
Here’s a little inside information from us: some audit surprises can be avoided with better records, and some mistakes can be corrected after submission. The trick is knowing what the carrier is looking for before the notice arrives.
Follow the Numbers
For many contractors, three figures deserve attention: gross revenue, payroll, and subcontractor costs. Your policy determines which figures are used to calculate premium.
General liability may be rated on sales, payroll, subcontracted work, or another basis. Workers’ compensation generally considers payroll and the work being performed.
If you estimated $500,000 in sales and actually generated $900,000, an auditable policy based on sales may produce additional premium. Hiring employees or increasing subcontracted work can also affect an audit when those exposures are part of the rating basis. The rates and policy terms control the calculation.
Ask us: “What is my premium based on, and what will the carrier verify?”Gross revenue is not the same as profit. Do not substitute the amount left after expenses for the sales figure requested.
Your Policy Year May Not Be Your Accounting Year
One mistake contractors make is submitting January through December totals when their policy started midyear. If your policy runs from June 1 through May 31, a calendar year profit and loss statement does not match that period. Prepare reports for the dates requested by the auditor and explain any differences.
A Late Payment Can Muddy the Picture
You completed a job in April. Your policy began in June. The customer finally paid in July. A P&L prepared on a cash basis may show that payment as July revenue, even though the work was performed before this policy began.
Flag it for us and the auditor. Provide the contract, invoice, completion records, and payment date so the proper treatment can be reviewed under your policy’s rating rules. Do not automatically remove it yourself, but do not assume the deposit date alone answers the question.
Keep Personal Money Separate
We have seen personal deposits mistaken for business revenue during an insurance audit. Lottery winnings, casino winnings, life insurance death benefits, and money from unrelated side jobs such as Uber can create confusion when deposited into the same account used for your contracting business.
Our advice: use a separate account for personal money. If you have already mixed those funds, keep documents showing where each deposit came from. We can help explain them to the auditor and request appropriate corrections. For side work, clarify who earned the money and whether it belongs to the insured business. The account alone does not determine audit treatment.
“My Subs Have Insurance” Needs Documentation
Collecting subcontractor certificates before work begins is much easier than chasing them after the audit notice arrives. Keep proof of the applicable coverage for the dates each subcontractor worked. Track expiration dates and retain earlier certificates when replacements arrive.
Check what coverage is shown. A certificate showing general liability does not establish that the subcontractor carries workers’ compensation. Keep certificates alongside executed subcontract agreements, invoices, and payment records. These documents help explain who performed the work, what they did, and what you paid them.
What About Workers’ Comp Waivers?
Contractors sometimes use “workers’ comp waiver” to describe an independent contractor agreement or exemption document. In Texas, an appropriate agreement, such as the applicable DWC-83 agreement for certain building and construction relationships, may help document independent contractor status.
Ask us which form applies, how it should be completed, and when it must be submitted. A signed form does not automatically guarantee that the carrier will exclude the subcontractor’s cost. The actual relationship and applicable requirements still matter.
A waiver of subrogation serves a different purpose. It does not establish that subcontractor labor should be excluded from your audit.
Build the Audit Folder While You Build the Jobs
Your carrier will tell you exactly what it needs. Start with:
- P&L and sales records covering the requested period.
- Payroll reports identifying employees, wages, and actual duties, plus supporting tax reports when requested.
- Subcontractor records showing work performed, dates, and amounts paid.
- Subcontractor certificates covering the time they worked.
- Executed contracts and subcontract agreements.
- Invoices and payment records, preserving any labor and material breakdowns.
- Applicable independent contractor agreements or exemption documents.
- Records explaining late payments and personal deposits that need separate review.
Ask us what payroll separation is permitted and what supporting records are required.
Made a Mistake? Ask to Correct It.
Sometimes the carrier gets something wrong. Sometimes the contractor reports an incorrect number, leaves out a certificate, or misunderstands the request. Receiving an audit bill does not mean an honest mistake cannot be addressed.
Contact us promptly. We can help you request a review and submit corrected information through the carrier’s process. Explain exactly what changed and provide supporting records. Ask about dispute deadlines and any payment requirements while the review is pending.
At Contractors Direct Insurance Agency, we regularly help customers revise and resubmit audit information, dispute findings, and negotiate audit premiums with carriers.
That may involve correcting the reporting period, clarifying payroll, supplying missing certificates, explaining personal deposits, or asking the carrier to reconsider charges. A reduction is not guaranteed, but a documented correction gives the carrier something concrete to review.
Ignoring the notice can make matters worse. Depending on the policy and applicable rules, missing information can lead to an estimated audit or noncompliance charges. Changing carriers does not necessarily eliminate the previous policy’s audit obligation.
A Little Preparation Beats a Big Surprise
Tell us when revenue, payroll, or subcontractor use changes significantly during the year. Keep records as the work happens, and review the audit results against those records.
Before you assume the bill is correct, or that it is too late to fix your submission, let us take a look.
Contractors Direct Insurance Agency
If you swing a hammer or turn a screw, we have the right insurance for you.
Phone: (512) 831-5241
Email: Clayton@ContractorsDirectInsurance.com
Audit treatment and premium adjustments depend on policy terms, carrier rules, applicable law, and supporting documentation.



